Hey, got your attention, didn’t it?
The bigger question is, which camp do you belong to? The “Oh god no, you’re beautiful and you don’t need to lose a pound!” group, or the “MAN THE HARPOONS! The BBW board is thataway.” cult?
It seems to me that there are two different approaches to the weight issue in America. Oh yes, we’re battling a weight problem. The biggest problem that I see is our vast issues with DEFINING the problem. Is the issue with eating disorders, making people wish to be as skinny as possible? Or is the issue the newest “big is beautiful” trend? I’ve got arguments for both, and an argument for myself (which I am not totally sure about).
Having never had a chronic eating disorder, I can’t say that I fully understand it. However, I have lived through an eating disorder with a good friend of mine. The desire to be as skinny and small as possible is truly consuming, and only through a lot of support and an incredible will to live did my friend do a complete turnaround. She was always beautiful. She just had to convince herself of it. This bout of eating disorders has been blamed on many things, such as cultural idols and the fashion industry.
Some information on eating disorders, found on the Statistics Page of the National Eating Disorders organization web site.
Significant increase in incidence of anorexia from 1935 to 1989 especially among young women 15-24.
A rise in incidence of anorexia in young women 15-19 in each decade since 1930.
The incidence of bulimia in 10-39 year old women TRIPLED between 1988 and 1993.
The average American woman is 5’4” tall and weighs 140 pounds. The average American model is 5’11” tall and weighs 117 pounds.
Most fashion models are thinner than 98% of American women (Smolak, 1996).











1-800-931-2237
and website: www.NationalEatingDisorders.org
Okay, so some of the statistics are Iggy-Pop old. You can’t deny that eating disorders are all over the public board, however. There is this huge rush of empowering “YOU ARE BEAUTIFUL AS YOU ARE!” statements, large amounts of backpedaling from the national and international fashion scene, and loads of new support groups for eating disorders. Frankly, the only way to be as skinny as this 2-5% of the naturally teeny population is to HAVE an eating disorder. So, hooray for the focus on improved body image?
There’s this fantastic double-standard though, see, because America also struggles with obesity. Diets are everywhere, fat people are ridiculed in other nations, our eating habits and lack of exercise pointed out as the culprits for our spreading girth. Supersize Me, anyone? “”Fat is TERRIBLE, and no one should be it! Wanna be fit, with a tiny waist and a toned bum? Go diet and lose weight, because being fat is the worst thing for your image EVAR.” But how fat is too fat? How much weight should I lose to be okay? The overarching answer seems to be “We’re not sure, but by golly, do the diet thing! IT’LL BE AWESOMMMEEEE.”

Harharhar, Americans are so fat. And the whole world wears their pants too low.
Anyhow, you see my problem. Oh horrors, don’t be anorexic! Gain weight! Be happy as a mid-sized person! Oh wow, lose some weight, because everyone needs to! Here’s this fadtastic new diet! Go be a mid-sized person?
WHERE ARE THE SUPPORT GROUPS FOR THE MID-SIZED PEOPLE? WHAT THE HECK IS MID-SIZED? Even the BMI standard is being kicked around as an insufficient way to tell “how fat?” The support groups scream “Be happy as you are! BE HEALTHY!” What the heck is a healthy weight? Sure, it depends on many factors. I think it depends on how your body image is. I think there’s too thin a line between “too skinny,” “too fat,” and “just right.” Go too far either way and I’m not sure what to think!
Anyhoo, I’ve gained forty pounds in the last five months or so. Wait, before you start screaming “NO WAI, YOU DON’T LOOK IT!” let me step on the scale and show you guys. Believe me, I’ve gained it. I now weigh 180 lbs. Last winter I weighed about 140. Mmmkay, so am I unhealthy?
Sure, it’s a pain in the butt because I don’t fit into a lot of the clothes I did before. But I can still run a mile without dying. I just spent three weeks hiking around China with no problems keeping up with my “skinnier” counterparts. I will still run after a horse in the field unwilling to be caught. I don’t necessarily “feel” the health effects of my forty extra pounds of chub/muscle (I’m pretty sure it’s not muscle.)
Clothes, however, are durn expensive. And I’m a broke college student.
The main culprit of this sudden weight gain would be my recently diagnosed hypothyroidism. See here for information on it, courtesy of the Endocrine Web. Among other exciting things, it means that my metabolism can be outrun by a one-legged sloth. I’ve also become a couch potato of sorts, thanks to the “Dear god I just want to sleep all day” effects of said hypothyroidism. I’m now on levothyroxine, which has helped my levels, but I still need to make some life changes thanks to this diagnosis.
So, I gotta lose some weight! “NOOOO YOU’RE BEAUTIFUL!” “YES, HERE’S THIS AWESOME DIET!” Go away! I’m gorgeous. I don’t need your stupid diet. I do need to modify mine, however, to adjust to my new metabolic issues. I also need to pick back up exercise. NOOO HORRORS, DIET! NOOO HORRORS, YOU’RE BEAUTIFUL! No horrors get off my case. I wanna at least fit into my clothes. I have never been below a size 10. Nor will I be! I just need to drop a couple pounds to regain my clothing. It doesn’t mean I’m going to acquire an eating disorder to do it, nor am I going to be perfectly happy with wherever my ever-slowing metabolism takes me!
I am forever going to be annoyed by this “body image” issue. It seems that whenever I say I want to lose weight, I’ve got the body image police screaming at me. Does anyone else feel like the body image police want you to have ONE version of yourself that you’re happy with? If I feel I’m mildly overweight, I’m told that my negative body image will turn me into a walking eating disorder. However, if I feel like having an extra cookie, I’m told to curb my negative eating habits because HORRORS I SHALL BE A FAT AND UGLY AMERICAN AND NO ONE WILL LOVE ME. Say what? I love my natural chub. It’s just the stuff that pads my organs and makes my hips not want to fit into my fantastic new size 14 pants that bothers me.
Anyone have thoughts on this? Did this make any sense? Reading through it, it seems totally incoherent. But maybe that’s because it’s three in the morning. I don’t need “YOU GO GIRL BE YOURSELF!” cheerleaders either. I really want a discussion! What in the world is this yo-yo double standard doing? I shall get myself another cup of coffee and await the answers that will undoubtedly come pouring in (because this blog is so popular and all.)

Harharhar, oh, internets.

Indy-cat knows I appreciate her considerable chub.